For those of you who have been watching ISU since the late 70's like myself, it is obvious the Sycamores have been left behind the other teams we used to be competitive with. The stadium is way below average. The coaching is always suspect. I will not blame the players because at least they are here and I believe they all want to win. Terre Haute is not a football town. How many of you realize Terre Haute is the largest city in Indiana that has never won, or even played, in an IHSAA state championship? The problems with the football program are complex and difficult to correct. Heck, even the band is weak. (Coming from a former Marching Sycamore from the mid-70's when we marched 200 instruments and got standing ovations AT Ball State and a Bengals game.) I could not believe they marched in t-shirts and shorts last Saturday. I presume due to the low 80 degree temps with low humidity which dropped to the 70's before the game ended,someone decided to go the high school look. Geesh! I watched probably all of, or parts of, a dozen games...not one band did not wear their uniforms. There are not even 100 members in the band this year. I know complaining about the band is not a priority to the readers of this forum, but I believe it is a big part of the overall experience of collegiate football and a good collegiate band has a big place in tthe atmosphere. Somewhere along the line, the ISU music department has forgotten they are to be a collegiate band and not a high school band. Looks like I will spend my time watching a quality program again this season - Wabash College. The one hour drive to watch the mess at Memorial Stadium is just not worth it. My hope is that we now have a president and A.D. that understand what a good football program looks like. I hope they can somehow figure out how to make the needed changes.
The problems aren’t too complex. But they’re deep and institutional. I’m going to refer to certain prior administrators and BOT members as “they.”
—They probably kept Raetz too long.
—They did untold damage when they botched the clandestine attempt to go non-scholarship in the early 2000s.
—Fuel to the fire was the Lou West hire (hey that rhymes!).
—Sanford up and leaving on that whim with his son hurt.
—Playing in a one-sided stadium is just embarrassing. It’s a laughing stock. But they won’t do anything about it and didn’t do anything about Hulman Center until they absolutely, positively had to.
—Extending Mallory may not pan out and was a questionable call at the time. The last two years were the easiest schedules ISU will ever see as MVFC members and he still couldn’t win let alone make the playoffs.
—Sanford and Miles proved you CAN win at ISU.
—Agree T.H. isn’t a football town but you can still draw 5000-6000 when they’re winning.
So:
—renovate or replace the stadium.
—If Englehart has a big year and ISU goes sub-.500 buy out Mallory and bring Steve in to excite and energize the alumni and locals. If Presby has a winning season someone may very well snatch him up as he will have proven he can build a D1 FCS program from scratch (at a school with only 1000 undergrads no less). He just beat #11 Mercer at Mercer.
—Keep raising money and work the portal. I just read there are a bunch of folks that have joined the ISU Investor Society and the Capital Campaign was a success. The money is there.
—And no one expects to beat IU/Purdue but get to the point where you put a scare into them like Sanford and Miles did (I’m still pissed at the PI no-call at IU all those years ago. Would’ve beat them).
—Be in the playoff discussion every other year or so.
If Mallory can beat EIU, take the IU paycheck, not get embarrassed at Montana, and win four MVFC games I would say the program is finally on an upward trajectory. Anything less? See my Englehart plan, above.