I find it funny that we're still way behind Loyola and Illinois state even though we swept both of them. Non-Con means so much to your RPI rating.
It means a lot when you don't win but it's just math. Your winning percentage is only 25% of the RPI equation. If you're going to lose games in the non-conference, they need to be against top tier opponents. The RPI is broken down into three weighted components:
1) Winning Percentage (25%)
2) Average Opponents' Winning Percentage (50%)
3) Average Opponents' Opponents' Winning Percentage (25%)
So if you bomb non-con, it is best to schedule top flight opponents so you can at least get a boost if they are successful. Moving on to postseason math:
The NCAA Division 1 Tournament is a 68 team tournament.
The National Invitation Tournament (NIT) is a 32 team tournament.
The CollegeInsider.com Postseason Tournament (CIT) is a 32 team tournament.
The College Basketball Invitational (CBI) is a 16 team tournament.
So that's 148 teams involved in some sort of postseason play. I believe there are 351 Division 1 men's programs as of this year. The NCAA handed down 8 bans due to APR restrictions: Alabama State, App State, Florida A&M, Houston Baptist, Lamar, San Jose State, Central Arkansas and Wisconin-Milwaukee. Additionally, Syracuse imposed a self ban for 2015. So now you have 342 teams vying for those 148 spots.
I know some of you folks are against "unimportant" tournaments but I will always contest that there is no such thing. Creighton built their place in the Valley by going to like 15 straight postseason tournaments and they used the shit out of that in recruiting. I would routinely read quotes from recruits saying "They haven't missed the postseason since I was in diapers" and the like. Further, any time you have young players on your roster, getting them more experience against top flight competition and the intensity of win or go home ball is beneficial.
Lastly, getting selected pretty much means you're considered to be in the Top 40% of college hoops programs. When you don't have the added bonus of finishing 8th in the Big Ten and getting in because you're a "high major in the Big Ten" this is an accomplishment IMO. Our goal should be to never fall out of that grouping, especially as an underfunded program from the best mid-major conference out there. This is how you build a long term, successful program that kids want to play at.